You only have to look at Kanza Marland’s photograph, staring at the reader from somewhere between contempt and constipation, to guess what this reviewer is all about. Once you see it backed up by Lauren Cooperesque headlines like ‘Unbothered’ and ‘Hardly Over-Powelling’ (for Russ Powell you see), you realise that Marland has all the hallmarks of the archetype wet-eared review thicko nobody wants coming within a thousand miles of their show.
Perhaps daunted by Broadway Baby’s target word count, Marland shows all her working out. Of Stand-Up Tragedy She writes: “If approached as an hour of thought-provoking varied performances, then Stand-Up Tragedy is incredibly successful and quite innovative. However, if entered with the expectations of an hour of stand-up, it is definitely not comedic enough.” Having satisfied herself that the show is not supposed to be an hour of stand-up, she proceeds to review it as an hour of stand-up. “Definitely not one for those wanting light-hearted Fringe comedy,” she concludes.
She has a pronounced tendency to say the same thing three times – ‘thought-provoking’ is one of her favourites, though she never reveals what thoughts have been provoked. This came to the fore when reviewing Katie Mulgrew, criticising her tendency to dwell on a joke too long with no less than five synonyms in one paragraph: “bit long-winded”, “a bit waffling”, “needing some good editing”, “quite repetitive”, “often summarising and recapping what she had just said slightly unnecessarily”. What Marland lacks in wisdom she makes up for in irony.
Marland believes everything she sees, and cannot be trusted to draw any conclusions beyond that. So the least said of her review of Phil Ellis – in which she was convinced that everything that went ‘wrong’ in the show was real – the better. But I’d advise Broadway Baby not to send her to a magic show, lest she hammer out 200 words about witchcraft and watch-smashing.
Filed Under: 1/2 Star, Broadway Baby, Edmund Rumania
Tagged with , 1/2 Star, Broadway Baby, Edmund Rumania, Katie Mulgrew, Phil Ellis, Russ Powell, Stand-Up Tragedy.